What is friendly fraud? A guide for merchants

Friendly fraud is a growing concern for e-commerce businesses, presenting a unique set of challenges. Often misunderstood or overlooked, friendly fraud can lead to significant financial losses and operational disruptions. This issue arises when customers dispute legitimate transactions, causing merchants to lose revenue and incur additional costs.

Recognizing the impact of friendly fraud is crucial for e-commerce merchants. By understanding its details, businesses can develop and implement strategies to protect themselves, reduce financial risks, and maintain healthy customer relationships.

What is friendly fraud?

Friendly fraud occurs when a customer makes a legitimate purchase with their credit card but later disputes the charge with their bank, claiming it was unauthorized. This can happen intentionally or unintentionally. Sometimes, customers forget they made the purchase, don’t recognize the merchant’s name on their statement, or want to avoid paying for the product or service.

Understanding the nature of friendly fraud is crucial for implementing effective measures to protect your business from its adverse effects.

True fraud vs. friendly fraud

True fraud involves transactions made without the cardholder’s consent, typically through stolen card information. Friendly fraud, however, happens when the customer disputes a legitimate purchase. Understanding the difference is crucial for implementing effective fraud prevention strategies.

Both types of fraud can harm a business, but they require different approaches for prevention and resolution.

Friendly fraud examples

Understanding how friendly fraud manifests in various scenarios can help e-commerce merchants identify and mitigate these risks. Here are some detailed examples of how friendly fraud can occur across different industries:

E-commerce

• Unrecognized Purchases: A customer buys a product online but later disputes the charge because they do not recognize the merchant’s name on their credit card statement. This often happens with businesses that operate under different trade names.
• Family Members: A family member, such as a child, uses the cardholder’s payment information to make a purchase without their knowledge. The cardholder then disputes the charge, believing it to be unauthorized.
• Buyer’s Remorse: Customers who regret a purchase may file a chargeback instead of seeking a return or refund through the merchant’s proper channels.
• Multiple Orders: Customers place multiple orders and then claim they only received part of the shipment, disputing charges for the items they actually received.

Subscription services (SaaS)

• Forgotten Subscriptions: Customers sign up for a subscription service, forget about it, and then dispute recurring charges months later, claiming they never authorized them.
• Trial Period Abuse: Users sign up for a free trial and forget to cancel before the trial period ends. They then dispute the initial subscription charge as unauthorized.
• Service Dissatisfaction: Users unhappy with the service may claim they never signed up for it, seeking a refund through a chargeback rather than contacting customer support.

Nonprofits

• Unrecognized Donations: Donors make contributions during fundraising campaigns but later do not recognize the charge on their statement and file a dispute.
• Impulse Giving: In the heat of a fundraising event, donors make contributions and later regret their decision, leading them to dispute the transaction.
• Unauthorized Use: Family members or friends use a donor’s payment information to make a donation without their permission, resulting in the donor disputing the charge.

Marketplaces

• Item Not Received Claims: Buyers purchase items from sellers on a marketplace platform and then claim they never received the products, even though they did, in order to get their money back while keeping the items.
• Condition Disputes: Buyers receive an item in good condition but later file a chargeback claiming it was damaged or not as described.
• Payment Confusion: Buyers mistakenly believe they were charged twice for the same item and dispute one of the charges, despite both transactions being legitimate.

Digital goods and services

• Content Access: Users purchase digital content such as eBooks, music, or video games, consume the content, and then file a chargeback claiming they never authorized the purchase.
• Virtual Goods: In online games or platforms, users buy virtual items or currency and then dispute the charges after using the items, exploiting the difficulty in proving virtual delivery.
• Software Downloads: Customers download software, use it, and then claim the charge was unauthorized to get the software for free.

Travel and hospitality

• No-Show Claims: Customers book hotel rooms or flights, fail to show up, and later dispute the charge claiming they never made the booking.
• Service Complaints: Guests unhappy with their stay or experience might file a chargeback claiming they never authorized the transaction instead of addressing their concerns with the service provider.
• Cancelled Reservations: Customers who cancel a reservation outside the refund window might dispute the charge claiming they never authorized the booking to circumvent the cancellation policy.

These examples highlight the various ways friendly fraud can occur, underscoring the importance of vigilance and robust fraud prevention measures across different sectors. By understanding these scenarios, merchants can better prepare to identify and combat friendly fraud in their businesses.

Curious about how to protect customer data in your payment processes? Gain essential insights into data privacy in payments and how to safeguard your business and customers.
Data privacy in payments: Essential insights for merchants

Friendly fraud vs. refund abuse

While friendly fraud involves disputing legitimate charges, refund abuse occurs when customers exploit a retailer’s return policies to gain unwarranted refunds or credits. Both are detrimental to businesses but require different approaches to address. Refund abuse typically involves taking advantage of lenient return policies, whereas friendly fraud leverages the chargeback process.

Distinguishing between these two types of abuse helps in developing targeted strategies to mitigate their impact.

How banks detect friendly fraud

Banks detect friendly fraud through various methods, including:

• Transaction monitoring: Continuous monitoring of transactions to identify unusual activity.
• Spending pattern analysis: Analyzing a customer’s spending habits to detect anomalies.
• Dispute investigation: Investigating claims thoroughly to determine if they are legitimate.

These methods help banks protect both themselves and merchants from fraudulent activities.

The impact of friendly fraud on e-commerce

Friendly fraud can have significant financial implications for e-commerce merchants, including:

• Financial losses: Merchants lose the revenue from the sale and may incur additional fees from the chargeback process.
• Increased costs: Handling disputes requires time and resources, increasing operational costs.
• Reputation damage: High chargeback rates can damage a merchant’s reputation, leading to higher processing fees or even the loss of payment processing capabilities.
• Operational disruption: Frequent chargebacks can disrupt normal business operations and cash flow.

Understanding these impacts can help merchants develop strategies to mitigate the effects of friendly fraud.

What percentage of chargebacks are friendly fraud?

Friendly fraud is a significant issue, accounting for an estimated 60-80% of all chargebacks. This high percentage underscores the importance of addressing friendly fraud as part of an overall chargeback management strategy.

Recognizing the prevalence of friendly fraud helps businesses prioritize their fraud prevention efforts.

How to fight friendly fraud chargebacks

Fighting friendly fraud chargebacks involves gathering compelling evidence to prove that the transaction was legitimate. Here are steps to help:

• Maintain detailed records: Keep comprehensive records of all transactions, including receipts, communications, and delivery confirmations.
• Use clear billing descriptors: Ensure your business name is easily recognizable on credit card statements.
• Provide excellent customer service: Resolve disputes directly with customers to prevent chargebacks.
• Respond promptly to chargebacks: Submit all necessary documentation within the required timeframe.
• Leverage fraud prevention tools: Use advanced tools and services like Signifyd to detect and prevent fraudulent transactions.

Implementing these steps can increase the likelihood of successfully disputing friendly fraud chargebacks.

How bank reconciliation detects fraud

Bank reconciliation helps detect fraud by comparing internal financial records with bank statements to identify discrepancies. Regular reconciliation can uncover unauthorized transactions, errors, and anomalies that may indicate fraudulent activity. Here’s how it works:

• Cross-checking records: Compare your sales records with bank deposits.
• Identifying discrepancies: Look for differences between recorded sales and actual bank deposits.
• Investigating anomalies: Investigate any discrepancies to determine if they result from fraud, errors, or timing differences.

Regular bank reconciliation can serve as a crucial tool in your fraud detection arsenal.

Effective strategies to prevent friendly fraud

Preventing friendly fraud requires a combination of proactive measures and advanced technologies:

• Educate customers: Communicate your return and refund policies to customers.
• Implement strong authentication: Use multi-factor authentication to verify the identity of customers.
• Monitor transactions: Continuously monitor transactions for unusual activity.
• Use fraud detection tools: Leverage tools that use machine learning and big data to detect fraud.
• Maintain clear records: Keep detailed records of all transactions, including communications and delivery confirmations.

Combining these strategies can help reduce the incidence of friendly fraud.

Want to understand the reasons behind credit card declines? Discover the 27 common reasons why credit cards are declined and how to address them.
27 reasons why credit cards are declined

Real-world use cases of friendly fraud

Understanding how friendly fraud manifests in different industries can help merchants develop tailored strategies to combat it. Here are some real-world examples:

• E-commerce: Customers order products online and later dispute the charges, claiming they never received them.
• SaaS companies: Users subscribe to software services and then dispute the recurring charges after using the service.
• Nonprofits: Donors make contributions and later dispute the charges, claiming unauthorized transactions.
• Marketplaces: Buyers purchase items from sellers and then file chargebacks, claiming they never received the products.

Recognizing these scenarios can help businesses identify and mitigate friendly fraud risks.

Future trends in fraud detection

The future of fraud detection is evolving, with several emerging trends:

• AI and machine learning: These technologies are becoming increasingly sophisticated, improving the ability to detect and prevent fraud.
• Blockchain: Offering decentralized and secure payment options, blockchain technology can increase transparency and reduce fraud.
• Biometric authentication: Using biometric data (fingerprints, facial recognition) adds an extra layer of security to transactions.
• Behavioral analytics: Analyzing customer behavior patterns can help identify and prevent fraudulent activities.

Staying informed about these trends can help businesses enhance their fraud prevention strategies.

How to choose the right fraud prevention solution

Selecting the right fraud prevention solution involves evaluating several factors:

• Compatibility: Ensure the solution integrates seamlessly with your existing systems.
• Accuracy: Look for solutions with high accuracy rates in detecting fraudulent transactions.
• Ease of use: Choose user-friendly solutions that require minimal training.
• Scalability: Ensure the solution can grow with your business and handle increasing transaction volumes.
• Customer support: Consider the availability and quality of support services.

Choosing the right solution can significantly enhance your ability to combat fraud.

Enhancing customer experience while preventing fraud

Balancing fraud prevention with a seamless customer experience is crucial for e-commerce success:

• Transparent policies: Clearly communicate your return, refund, and dispute policies to customers.
• Streamlined processes: Make it easy for customers to contact you and resolve issues directly.
• Secure payments: Use secure payment gateways and authentication methods to protect customer data.
• Personalized support: Offer personalized customer support to address disputes and concerns promptly.

Ensuring a positive customer experience while preventing fraud can help build trust and loyalty.

FAQs about friendly fraud and refund abuse

How can I differentiate between friendly fraud and true fraud?
True fraud involves unauthorized transactions using stolen payment information, while friendly fraud occurs when a legitimate transaction is disputed by the customer as fraudulent.

What steps can I take to prevent refund abuse?

To prevent refund abuse, clearly communicate your return policies, limit the number of allowable returns, and track customer return patterns to identify potential abuse.

How do fraud detection tools help in identifying friendly fraud?

Fraud detection tools use advanced algorithms and machine learning to analyze transaction data and identify patterns indicative of friendly fraud, helping to flag suspicious activities.

What are the consequences of committing friendly fraud?

Consumers committing friendly fraud risk legal consequences, account closures, blacklisting from services, and damaged relationships with merchants.

Can friendly fraud be reduced through customer education?

Yes, educating customers about the impact of friendly fraud and providing clear billing descriptors can reduce the occurrence of friendly fraud.

How do chargebacks affect a merchant’s reputation?

High chargeback rates can damage a merchant’s reputation, leading to higher processing fees, stricter fraud prevention measures, and even loss of payment processing capabilities.

Why is regular bank reconciliation important for detecting fraud?

Regular bank reconciliation helps detect unauthorized transactions, errors, and discrepancies, providing an early warning system for potential fraud.

What role does customer service play in preventing friendly fraud?

Excellent customer service can resolve disputes directly with customers, reducing the likelihood of chargebacks and maintaining positive customer relationships.

Are there industry-specific strategies for combating friendly fraud?

Yes, different industries may require tailored strategies based on their unique challenges and customer behaviors, such as stricter verification processes or more detailed transaction records.

How can I effectively respond to a chargeback claim for friendly fraud?

Gather all relevant evidence, including transaction receipts, communications, and delivery confirmations, and submit a thorough and timely response to the chargeback claim.

Struggling with chargebacks? Find out how to avoid and control them in 2024 with these effective strategies.
Chargebacks: How to avoid and control them in 2024

Contact Gr4vy to book a demo for Gr4vy’s no-code rules engine, Flow, which lets you orchestrate and optimize your backend and frontend payments workflow. Reduce fraud, chargebacks, processing fees, and the overall transaction cost—all without engineering support.