What’s next for payments, from AI to open banking and global real-time rails? As technology pushes boundaries, are we building a smarter, more connected payments system, or just adding layers of complexity? On Behind the Checkout, Gr4vy’s podcast, John Lunn, Founder and CEO of Gr4vy, explores those questions with Davide Villa, manager at Edgar, Dunn & Company, who advises leading financial institutions and merchants on payment strategy and transformation. The conversation below is lightly edited for clarity.
Key insights from the episode
Davide Villa is a manager at Edgar, Dunn & Company, where he advises leading financial institutions and merchants on payment strategy and transformation.
John Lunn is Founder and CEO of Gr4vy, the cloud-native payment orchestration platform.
John Lunn: Davide, it’s great to have you on the show.
Davide Villa: It’s a pleasure to be here, John. I’m looking forward to an interesting conversation.
John Lunn: Let’s get deep into it, starting with a hard question. When you look at today’s payment ecosystem, what excites you most, and what worries you?
Davide Villa: A couple of things are really exciting. The first is that payments is increasingly becoming a strategic consideration for businesses trying to accelerate, rather than just being seen as a cost. We see a lot of merchants using many PSP and acquirer connections to optimize acceptance, reduce costs and personalize the checkout experience. As you mentioned, there are also many new infrastructure rails enabling alternative ways of transferring funds and new business models: RTP, account funding transactions, many new types of wallets and stablecoins. We’re also seeing a lot of embedded finance, which is a recurring theme in our work: embedded payments, embedded issuing, embedded loans, all of which creates new value, especially for software companies. And finally, and I know it’s going to come up at some point, so let’s get it out of the way, agentic commerce is obviously very exciting. There’s a lot of hype around it, and it’s important to understand what it is and how it will actually affect payments.
“Payments is more and more becoming a strategic consideration for a lot of businesses that are trying to accelerate rather than just being seen as a cost.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company
As for what worries me, you mentioned it earlier: there’s a lot of complexity. Merchants are becoming more sophisticated in their understanding of payments, but there’s still a lot of complexity in all the alternative payment methods, the available risk tools, and the compliance requirements when you expand into new geographies or add new layers. Many merchants without big engineering teams are struggling to manage it. So my main worry is that the ideas are good, but implementation is becoming hard, or costly, to a certain extent.
“Ideas are good, but the implementation is becoming hard to certain extent or costly.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company
John Lunn: We might have an answer for that, but let’s move on. How have the last two years redefined what innovation means in payments? There was a big movement toward anything that wasn’t credit cards, and I feel that has changed a bit. How do we redefine innovation in payments?
Davide Villa: It’s a really interesting question, because at Edgar, Dunn we publish a yearly report on what’s new in payments, and this question made me go back to what we published two years ago. We were coming out of the pandemic, which had boosted certain types of businesses. We were talking about fintechs emerging to boost operational efficiency, and about climate and impact fintechs trying to shed light on sustainability in financial services, which we don’t see as much anymore. We were talking about AI, but ChatGPT had only just come out, so the question was still what generative AI is and what it could mean for payments.
Today we have a better understanding of what AI means for transforming businesses and operations, using orchestration that moves from rules to autonomy. Buy Now, Pay Later has grown significantly, so we talk a lot about that, along with biometrics and digital identity. And there are more real applications of these new technologies, such as connected cars, insurtech, payments in virtual economies and stablecoins. So a lot has actually changed over the last few years.
John Lunn: A follow-on question, and let’s put agentic to one side, because that’s too obvious an answer. What are your clients asking you about now that they weren’t asking before? What’s top of mind for them?
Davide Villa: They’re asking about some of the same root topics, such as how to get better visibility of their costs and profitability. As I said, merchants understand scheme fees, cross-border fees, fraud and disputes a bit better, but they still want to know more about reducing the impact of interchange and looking at downgrades, and about managing disputes better and fighting chargebacks they consider friendly fraud rather than legitimate disputes. How do I reduce my operational overhead? In our view, there’s a lot of margin pressure globally and fees are rising, so merchants are trying to optimize as much as possible.
They’re also asking which KPIs they should evaluate as performance metrics. Authorization rates, latency and false declines are no longer topics only ingrained in the payments team; they’re actually being looked at at board level. These metrics have evolved and expanded within merchants. And then, as always, operational efficiency and automation. We get this a lot: how can I use automation to fight disputes? How can I use AI to create responses to chargebacks, or to reconcile payments and review all these processes? How can I automate as much as I can? We’re getting those questions more and more compared with the last few years. And then, as you mentioned, everyone is asking about agentic commerce.
“Authorization rates, latency, false declines, they’re becoming topics that are not as much ingrained within pure payments team, also they’re looked at actually at the board level.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company
John Lunn: The next question is about consolidation and fragmentation. Think back three years: it was all about alternatives to credit cards. Open banking and real-time payments were going to change everything, Buy Now, Pay Later was going to disrupt borrowing, and so on. There was a lot of fragmentation, with new kings coming in to compete with the standard card rails. It feels to me like that’s gone backwards, or at least not changed. Outside of agentic and AI, I think the two most exciting things in payments last year were Visa, Mastercard and Amex coming together to create Click to Pay, which I think is an exciting innovation, along with the tokenization that comes with it, and the banks coming together to build Paze. Both are driven by old-school financial institutions, not startups. Do you feel it’s getting concentrated, or are we still in a world where new payment methods will come from startups and fast-growing tech companies?
Davide Villa: It’s a very interesting point, because I think both are happening. There is both consolidation and fragmentation, but at different layers within the payments ecosystem. Click to Pay and Paze are actually examples of more fragmentation at the consumer layer. In Europe, there’s also Wero, which tries to consolidate more of the domestic wallets. They show that consumers have more choice at checkout than before, and Paze and Click to Pay are, at the end of the day, card-centric solutions. But more countries are trying to move away from relying on Visa and Mastercard and are pushing for more domestic solutions. More domestic schemes are being developed in certain markets, and more real-time payment schemes are launching. UPI was obviously a big success from the mid-2010s, and there’s Pix, and also Bre-B in Colombia. There’s a lot of innovation there, so at the consumer level there are a lot of options.
On the merchant side, there’s more willingness to consolidate. Merchants want to diversify payment processors, but they don’t want to manage all the individual relationships needed to accept every option consumers have. So there’s a willingness at the merchant level to consolidate: to have unified reporting, and to manage risk from a single point, rather than having different risk criteria across countries and payment methods. So, to answer your question, both are happening, and it’s very exciting to see.
“There is both consolidation and fragmentation, but it’s a different layers within the payments ecosystem.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company
John Lunn: But if you look at the markets where real-time payment infrastructure has taken off, UPI in India, Pix in Brazil, Bre-B and so on, they’ve all been markets where credit cards weren’t strong to start with, whereas real-time payments haven’t really succeeded where cards were strong. In the UK, I think the real-time payments and open banking experiment has had mixed results. It’s been very successful in opening up banking, but it hasn’t done much for payments, apart from areas like bill payments and areas where credit cards struggle, like, unfortunately, not-safe-for-work content. So I wonder whether it’s getting more fragmented geographically rather than technically.
Davide Villa: Absolutely. And it’s not just that cards weren’t as prevalent in those markets. These new solutions were also mandated by regulators, mandated on the banks, and they were cheaper to accept than cards. Being mandated by the local authorities meant more readiness and adoption, compared with, as you said, the US, where FedNow hasn’t had the same level of adoption, partly because it’s been left to the market, and cards have a good incentive ecosystem that keeps everyone using cards rather than adopting something that disrupts that model.
John Lunn: We’re also lazy by nature, aren’t we? If something’s easy, we won’t change unless there’s a real reason to.
Davide Villa: That’s correct, yes.
John Lunn: Outside of agentic, AI and automation are reshaping the merchant and consumer payment experience, and how fraudsters attack merchants. How are you seeing AI and automation reshape payments generally?
Davide Villa: Aside from agentic commerce, which I don’t think will necessarily change the payment experience itself very much, AI and automation are where we’ll really see impact on the payment experience. I think they’ll just make everything a bit more efficient over time. On the consumer side, you may see fewer card declines, smarter authorization models enabling more invisible payments, and more personalized payment options, so overall less friction for consumers paying. But it won’t be an overhaul of how we pay today. On the merchant side, as I mentioned, there’ll be better responses to disputes and chargebacks using AI, optimized fraud models as machine learning gets better and better, seamless reconciliation, and issuer-specific routing decisions based on AI learning and reading metrics that were harder to understand before.
“It’s not going to be an overhaul of how we pay today.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company, on AI in payments
John Lunn: Absolutely. But on the other side, it’s making it a lot easier to be a fraudster. One of our other guests said that even a five-year-old could use a card testing tool now. Unfortunately, anti-fraud in payments is an arms race, and we now have a new nuclear bomb, as it were, that works for both sides.
John Lunn: What’s the big unlock for cross-border, an area of frustration for a lot of merchants given the price of cross-border transactions? Let’s leave tariffs to one side and talk about cross-border payments themselves. Are stablecoins the big unlock?
Davide Villa: I think stablecoins are one of the big opportunities. I also think interlinking real-time payment systems is a big opportunity. That’s happening primarily in Southeast Asia, with pilots in Singapore, Thailand and the Philippines. Having an instant payment solution connected between markets is a big opportunity for cross-border commerce. I’m not sure what the fees would be, but theoretically these are very low-cost payment solutions.
Another exciting cross-border opportunity is portable digital identity and tokenization: using my proxy for a given real-time payment solution and being able to use it in a different market to make a payment. That’s very exciting, though still very early stage. And then, as you mentioned, stablecoins are obviously a big opportunity, particularly for managing treasury operations. A big example from a few months ago, or maybe a year ago now, is SpaceX using stablecoins to accept payments for Starlink in different countries, specifically in Latin America, moving funds from stablecoins to US dollars and basically managing operations in stablecoins. That’s very interesting, and we’ll see whether more businesses operating internationally adopt that model, but it’s definitely a big opportunity.
John Lunn: Interesting. Did they have particular reasons? Some of the markets they worked in perhaps had quite volatile currencies and exchange rates. Do you see more of this happening?
Davide Villa: Volatile currencies, for sure, and exchange rates that aren’t ideal. Instead, you pay an on-ramp fee and potentially keep the funds in stablecoins, then off-ramp as you need to. You don’t even need to convert to US dollars. You can keep the funds in stablecoins and, depending on where you have expenses, off-ramp directly from stablecoins to the local currency you need. So it cuts out an area of friction, uncertainty and potential risk, and keeps the process more streamlined.
“You can keep it in stablecoin and then depending on whether you have expenses in certain markets off-ramp directly from stablecoin to the local currency.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company
John Lunn: Everybody likes to say regulators hinder innovation. I totally disagree; I believe regulators have a job to protect consumers from us crazy tech people trying to do everything. But they’re adding new frameworks. We’ve got PSD3 coming, the VAMP program from Visa, and other new rules, not all of them regulation as such. Are they hindering innovation, or just giving us new challenges and making us think harder?
Davide Villa: I think they’re both helping and hindering innovation. Frameworks like PSD3, FedNow and VAMP are trying to foster innovation by providing a secure, efficient and level playing field for companies. But at the same time, as you mentioned, they increase compliance costs and bring restrictions and complexity. I hadn’t thought of VAMP when thinking of regulators, but VAMP is causing a lot of headaches for a lot of businesses. I understand why Visa is doing it, but we get a lot of questions: what does VAMP mean, how should I prepare for it, which ratios do I need to look at now? There’s a lot of confusion, especially for smaller firms. Regulators do have a job to help, and PSD3, in my view, is a good framework for providing a level playing field for many businesses, but these frameworks also add complexity. It’s a fine line between trying to help and avoiding hindering.
John Lunn: I think we have to remember who they’re there to protect, and it’s definitely not our bottom lines.
John Lunn: Card networks: are they evolving fast enough to stay relevant, or will they eventually be eaten by everything else?
Davide Villa: I don’t think they’re going to be eaten. The networks are so well entrenched in what they’ve built and the relationships they have, and they are evolving. Expectations are very high, of course, and innovation is perhaps moving faster than the card networks, but they’ve made strong progress: tokenization, identity, security and data services have all seen continued investment. They’re providing services for agentic commerce; Visa and Mastercard were among the first to offer solutions there. So they’re playing a role in agentic commerce, though you could argue they’re also slowing it down by delaying, or struggling to provide, a solution for agentic network tokenization. And stablecoins, which you could argue are a threat to the card networks, are something both Visa and Mastercard are investing in and looking into. So I don’t think they’ll be marginalized in the future payments landscape. Like it or not, they’re here to stay, even with competition from instant, low-cost, push-based payments on bank-to-bank rails.
“Like it or not, they’re here to stay.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company, on the card networks
John Lunn: We had Hans Morris from Nyca, the former president of Visa, on the podcast, and he was basically saying that cash is the main target for these alternative payment types, not the card networks, and that they don’t really affect the card networks much. The networks have been running for years, they still work and they work pretty well, so there are more inefficient things to go after.
Davide Villa: I definitely agree. The card networks play in every use case you can think of that involves payments: domestic consumer, P2P, B2B, cross-border. They’re everywhere. You could argue that additional companies and solutions are coming in to take a bit of share, some more successfully than others, but they’re not going to erode everything the card networks do.
John Lunn: I agree. We always like to ask the crystal ball question at the end. Predicting the future is a dangerous game, but we like to do it. Make one prediction about how people will be paying in 2030.
Davide Villa: As you said, it’s a dangerous question, and I’m likely to get it wrong.
John Lunn: It’s okay to be wrong. It’s completely fine.
Davide Villa: But if I take a logical approach and compare five years ago with now, there’s been a lot of innovation, yet you could argue how we pay hasn’t changed that much. It’s more mobile-centric than before, but the form factors haven’t changed much. So my prediction is that by 2030 we’ll still be paying with cards and mobile, but payment will become more invisible than before, more embedded in the experience, like Uber. You’ll have the option to choose between card, bank transfer and wallet, but payment will be embedded more and more in the consumer’s journey. So that’s perhaps a conservative prediction of how we’ll pay in 2030.
“We’re still going to be paying with cards, mobile, but the payment is going to become more invisible than before.”
Davide Villa, manager, Edgar, Dunn & Company
John Lunn: I really appreciate your time today, Davide, and thank you for coming on the podcast. I look forward to seeing you at the next event.
Davide Villa: Thank you.
Watch more conversations with payments leaders in the Behind the Checkout series. To see how a payment orchestration platform consolidates providers, reporting and risk management while giving consumers the payment methods they want, through a single integration, talk to the Gr4vy team.
As brands, platforms and payment providers compete for the final, critical interaction, the last click,…
The AI-powered intelligence assistant enables merchants to analyze payment performance across multiple providers, investigate declines,…
Invisible payments are reshaping how we buy, sell and engage, often without us realizing it.…
Pay by bank, also known as bank-to-bank, account-to-account or open banking payments, is evolving fast…
From Apple Pay and Google Pay to Click to Pay and PayPal, a new wave…
In the first episode of Behind the Checkout, Gr4vy's podcast, John Lunn, Founder and CEO…