Credit card processing fees: all you need to know as a merchant

Understanding credit card processing fees is essential for any merchant looking to manage costs and maximize profitability. These fees, often viewed as a necessary part of doing business, can significantly impact your bottom line. Whether you’re running a small boutique or managing a large e-commerce platform, knowing how credit card processing fees work, who pays them, and how to navigate the complexities surrounding them is crucial for your financial success.

What is a typical credit card processing fee?

Credit card processing fees typically range from 1.5% to 3.5% per transaction, depending on various factors. These fees are made up of three main components:

• Interchange Fees: These are the largest portion of the processing fee and are paid to the card-issuing bank. Interchange fees vary depending on the type of card used (debit, credit, rewards), the transaction type (in-person, online), and the merchant’s industry.
• Assessment Fees: These fees are charged by the card networks (such as Visa, Mastercard, or American Express) and are used to cover the cost of maintaining the payment network.
• Processor Markup: This fee is charged by the payment processor for facilitating the transaction. The processor markup can be a flat fee, a percentage of the transaction, or a combination of both.

For example, if you sell an item for $100, and your processing fee is 2.9% + $0.30, you would pay $3.20 in fees, leaving you with $96.80 from the transaction.

Why fees vary

The variation in credit card processing fees can be attributed to several factors:

1. Card Type: Premium credit cards, such as rewards or business cards, often have higher interchange fees than standard debit cards.
2. Transaction Method: Card-present transactions (in-store) typically incur lower fees compared to card-not-present transactions (online or over-the-phone) due to the lower risk of fraud.
3. Industry: Different industries have different risk profiles, which can influence the fees. For example, high-risk industries like travel or online gaming may face higher fees.

Who pays the 3% credit card fee?

In most cases, the merchant is responsible for paying the credit card processing fee, which is usually around 3% of the transaction amount. This fee is deducted from the total amount of the sale before the funds are deposited into the merchant’s account. For instance, if a customer makes a $100 purchase and the processing fee is 3%, the merchant will receive $97, with $3 going towards covering the fee.

This system ensures that the merchant bears the cost of accepting credit card payments, which is considered a necessary expense for the convenience and security it offers both the merchant and the customer.

Impact on small businesses

For small businesses, these fees can add up quickly, especially if they operate on thin margins. Understanding the fee structure and how it affects your revenue is crucial for maintaining profitability. Some small businesses may choose to pass these fees on to customers, either by increasing prices or by adding a surcharge.

Can I pass on credit card fees to customers?

Yes, merchants can pass on credit card processing fees to customers in the form of a surcharge, but there are important considerations and legalities to be aware of. The practice of adding a surcharge to cover credit card fees is known as “credit card surcharging.”

Legal considerations

The legality of surcharging varies depending on where your business is located. In the United States, surcharging is legal in most states, but there are specific states where it is prohibited or restricted. For example, states like California, Florida, and New York have had varying laws regarding surcharges. It’s essential to check your local regulations and ensure compliance with both state laws and the policies set by the card networks (Visa, Mastercard, etc.).

How to implement surcharges

If you decide to implement a surcharge, you must:

1. Notify Customers: Clearly inform customers about the surcharge before they complete the transaction. This can be done through signage at the point of sale or on the payment page of your website.
2. Cap the Surcharge: Ensure that the surcharge does not exceed the cost of processing the payment. Most card networks limit the surcharge to 4% of the transaction or the actual processing fee, whichever is lower.
3. Itemize the Surcharge: On the receipt, the surcharge should be itemized separately from the sale amount to ensure transparency.

Want to learn more about recurring payments and how they can benefit your business? Recurring Payments Explained breaks down everything you need to know about setting up and managing these payments effectively.

Is it OK to charge a credit card processing fee?

Charging a credit card processing fee is legal in many places, but it must be done with transparency and in accordance with local laws and card network regulations. Transparency is key—customers should be fully aware of any additional charges before completing their purchase.

Customer perception

While legal, adding a surcharge can affect customer perception. Some customers may view it as unfair or as an attempt to pass on business costs to them. Therefore, it’s important to consider how surcharges might impact customer loyalty and whether they are necessary for your business model.

Why are card processing fees so high?

Credit card processing fees might seem high due to the multiple parties involved in a transaction. These parties include the issuing bank, the acquiring bank, the card networks, and the payment processor. Each entity plays a role in processing the payment and takes a cut for their services.

Factors contributing to high fees

1. Risk Management: Credit card transactions, especially online ones, come with higher fraud risks. The fees help cover the cost of fraud detection, chargebacks, and other security measures.
2. Premium Cards: Cards offering rewards, cashback, or travel points often have higher interchange fees, which are passed on to merchants.
3. Currency Conversion: For international transactions, additional fees may apply for currency conversion, further increasing the cost of processing.

Can merchants charge 2% extra on credit card payments?

Yes, merchants can charge an extra fee on credit card payments, but this practice is regulated. Typically, merchants can impose a surcharge to cover the cost of processing the payment, but this surcharge cannot exceed the actual cost. For most credit card transactions, the fee ranges between 1.5% and 3.5%.

Compliance requirements

To comply with legal and card network requirements, merchants must:

• Ensure the surcharge is within legal limits: For example, if your processing fee is 2%, you cannot charge more than 2% as a surcharge.
• Clearly communicate the surcharge to customers: Before completing the transaction, customers must be informed of any additional charges.

Boost your payment success by understanding approval rates. Approval Rates in Payments provides an in-depth analysis of what affects your approval rates and how to improve them in 2024.

How to notify customers of credit card surcharges?

Notifying customers of credit card surcharges is essential to maintain transparency and compliance with regulations. Here’s how you can do it effectively:

1. Signage: If you operate a physical store, place clear signage at the point of sale indicating that a surcharge will be applied to credit card transactions.
2. Online Notifications: For e-commerce businesses, include a notice on the payment page, explaining that a surcharge will be added to credit card payments. Ensure this notice is visible before the customer enters their payment information.
3. Receipts: Itemize the surcharge on the receipt, so customers can see the exact amount they were charged and understand why.

Example of a surcharge notice

“Please note: A 2% surcharge will be applied to all credit card transactions. This fee helps cover the cost of processing your payment securely.”

Are credit card processing fees negotiable?

Yes, credit card processing fees are negotiable, especially for businesses with higher transaction volumes. Payment processors are often willing to lower fees to secure or retain your business.

How to negotiate processing fees

1. Understand Your Volume: Know your monthly transaction volume and average ticket size. Higher volumes often give you more leverage in negotiations.
2. Shop Around: Compare offers from different payment processors. Use competitive quotes to negotiate better terms.
3. Ask About Interchange-Plus Pricing: This pricing model offers more transparency and could potentially lower your overall fees compared to flat-rate pricing.
4. Negotiate Additional Fees: Beyond the per-transaction fees, there may be monthly fees, chargeback fees, or PCI compliance fees that you can negotiate.

Ever wondered why a credit card transaction gets declined? 27 Reasons Why Credit Cards Are Declined offers a detailed look at the most common causes and how you can prevent them.

FAQs about credit card processing fees

Can I avoid credit card processing fees altogether?

• It’s challenging to avoid these fees entirely, but you can minimize them by negotiating with processors, using lower-cost payment methods, or passing fees onto customers (where legal).

What are the hidden fees in credit card processing?

• Hidden fees may include chargeback fees, statement fees, PCI compliance fees, and monthly minimum fees. Always read the fine print of your processing agreement.

How do high processing fees impact my business?

• High processing fees can eat into your profit margins, particularly if you operate on thin margins or deal with many small transactions. It’s essential to understand these fees and factor them into your pricing strategy.

Is there a difference in fees between credit and debit card transactions?

• Yes, debit card transactions generally have lower interchange fees than credit card transactions, especially for PIN-based debit transactions.

How can I reduce credit card processing fees?

• To reduce fees, consider negotiating with your payment processor, choosing a processor with lower rates, encouraging customers to use lower-cost payment methods, and ensuring you’re using the appropriate transaction codes for your industry.

Credit card processing fees are an unavoidable aspect of accepting payments, but understanding how they work and managing them effectively can make a significant difference to your business’s profitability. By knowing who pays these fees, whether you can pass them on to customers, and how to negotiate them, you can make informed decisions that benefit your bottom line.Managing these fees strategically is key to maintaining a healthy profit margin, especially for small businesses. If you’re looking for ways to optimize your payment processing and reduce fees, contact Gr4vy today to learn how our payment orchestration solutions can help streamline your operations and maximize your revenue.